The Sneakiest Tricks Retailers Pull During Big Sales (And How to Spot a Real Deal)
Big sale events are exciting. They’re also carefully engineered to get you to spend more than you planned, on things you didn’t need, at prices that aren’t always as good as they look. Retailers spend millions of dollars designing the psychology of a sale. The least you can do is know what you’re walking into.
Here are the most common tricks retailers use during major sale events like Prime Day, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday, and what a real deal looks like by comparison.
🚨 The Tricks
1. Fake “Original Prices”
This is the most common and most profitable trick in retail. A product that normally sells for $40 gets its “original price” set to $80 two weeks before the sale, then gets marked down to $50 during the event. The banner says “38% off.” The math is technically accurate. The deal is not real.
The Federal Trade Commission has rules about this, but enforcement is inconsistent and the practice is widespread. Retailers know that a crossed-out price with a percentage badge is one of the most powerful visual triggers for purchasing behavior.
How to spot it: Check the price history. On Amazon, CamelCamelCamel shows you a full graph of what the product has sold for over time. If the “original price” only appeared in the two weeks before the sale, that’s your answer. For other retailers, Google the product name plus “price history”; tools like Honey and Capital One Shopping track prices at many major retailers as well.
2. Countdown Timers That Reset
Urgency is a powerful sales tool. “Only 3 hours left!” creates pressure to buy before you’ve thought it through. The problem is that many countdown timers aren’t tied to anything real. Some reset after they expire. Some apply to rolling 24-hour windows that restart automatically. Some are purely decorative.
The same applies to “Only 2 left in stock!” warnings. Sometimes that’s true. Often it’s a permanent fixture designed to create scarcity whether or not inventory is low.
How to spot it: Note the time on a countdown and check back after it expires. If the deal is still running, the timer was theater. For stock warnings, refresh the page a few hours later. If the number hasn’t changed, it probably isn’t tracking real inventory.
3. Doorbusters That Were Never in Stock
Big box retailers are known for advertising doorbuster deals with extremely limited quantities, sometimes as few as one or two units per store. The deal is real, but the availability is nearly impossible. The actual purpose is to get you in the door (or to the site) where you’ll browse and buy other things at regular prices.
Online retailers do a version of this with Lightning Deals on Amazon: limited-quantity deals that sell out within minutes. Some are genuine bargains. Others are mediocre discounts on products with inflated starting prices, designed to create urgency around a deal that isn’t worth rushing for.
How to spot it: For in-store doorbusters, read the fine print on advertised quantities. For Lightning Deals, check the price history before claiming one. If the Lightning Deal price is close to what the product has sold for all year, the urgency isn’t serving you.
4. Bundle Inflation
You’ve seen this one: “Buy the set and save 30%!” But the set includes three things you wanted and two you didn’t, and the price of the items you wanted individually is lower than your share of the bundle price. The “savings” only exist if you wanted all five items at the prices they’ve assigned to each one in the bundle.
Bundles are especially common in beauty, skincare, and electronics accessories. The anchor is almost always a popular item paired with slower-moving inventory that benefits from the halo effect.
How to spot it: Price out the items you want individually before buying a bundle. If the bundle is cheaper for the items you want, it’s a real deal. If it’s only cheaper when you include the items you didn’t want, it isn’t.
5. Free Shipping Thresholds Designed to Make You Overspend
“Free shipping on orders over $35” sounds like a benefit. It is, if you were already spending $35. If you were spending $28, you’ve just been given a financial incentive to add $7 of stuff you didn’t need to avoid a $5 shipping fee. The math on that doesn’t work in your favor.
How to spot it: Calculate whether the items you’re adding to reach the threshold are things you’d buy anyway. If you’re adding something just to hit the number, compare the cost of those items to the shipping fee you’re avoiding. Sometimes it makes sense. Often it doesn’t.
6. The “Compare At” Number That Comes From Nowhere
You’ll see this often at off-price retailers and outlet stores: “Compare at $120, Our price $49.” The “compare at” price is supposed to represent what the item sells for elsewhere. In practice, it’s often a manufacturer’s suggested retail price that no one ever pays, a price from a retailer that doesn’t exist, or a number that was simply chosen to make the discount look dramatic.
How to spot it: Search the product online. If you can’t find the “compare at” price being charged anywhere, it isn’t a real reference point.
7. Sale Prices That Are Permanent
Some retailers run continuous sales where everything is technically “on sale” all the time. The sale price is the real price. The strikethrough is decoration. This is especially common in furniture and mattress retail, where a “sale” that has been running for 18 months isn’t a sale at all.
How to spot it: If a site always has a sitewide percentage off, or if the same items have been “on sale” every time you’ve visited, the sale price is the price. Shop accordingly, but don’t feel urgency about the discount expiring.
8. Loyalty Points That Are Harder to Redeem Than They Look
Earning points during a sale sounds like an added bonus. But points programs often have expiration dates, minimum redemption thresholds, redemption blackout periods, and category restrictions that make them harder to use than they appear. Earning 500 points sounds great until you discover they expire in 90 days and require 1,000 points to redeem.
How to spot it: Before a major purchase at a points-earning retailer, read the redemption rules. Know the expiration policy and whether the points you’re earning are enough to be useful on their own or require future purchases to unlock.
✅ What a Real Deal Looks Like
Not every sale is a trick. Real deals exist. Here’s what they tend to have in common:
The price is at or near a historical low. Check price history. A genuine sale brings a product to a price point it rarely hits. You can verify this in about 30 seconds with CamelCamelCamel or a browser extension.
The discount is on something you were already going to buy. The best deals are on items already on your list. A 40% discount on something you don’t need isn’t savings.
The original price is real. When you look at price history, the “original” or “regular” price matches what the product has sold for most of the time.
There’s no artificial urgency required. A good deal is a good deal whether you buy it in the next 10 minutes or the next hour. Genuine limited availability is possible, but if you feel panicked, that’s worth pausing to examine.
You can verify it at competing retailers. If Amazon has something at a sale price, check Target, Walmart, and Best Buy. If it’s cheaper elsewhere, buy it there. If it’s priced similarly, the Amazon deal is probably in the right ballpark.
You can stack it with cash back. The best deals get even better when a retailer is running elevated cash back through Rakuten. During bonus cash back events, it’s common to see 10%+ back at major retailers, on top of whatever sale price is already running. If the timing lines up, that’s when a good deal becomes a great one. Sign up for Rakuten here if you’re not already using it.
The Mindset That Protects You
The most useful reframe for shopping during big sale events: you’re not trying to find deals, you’re trying to buy specific things at the best available price. Going into a sale with a list and price targets keeps you in a different mode than browsing for deals to capitalize on.
Retailers are very good at generating the feeling that you’re winning when you buy during a sale. The tools to verify whether that feeling is accurate are free, fast, and worth using every time.
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support!
